By replacing its traditional aeration process lobe air blowers with modern Atlas Copco VSD rotary screw blowers, Scottish Water’s Nigg wastewater treatment works now achieves continuous, uninterrupted operation, with a reduced maintenance programme and savings of up to 25% of its energy costs − plus the potential for further savings when the system is fully optimised. The Nigg wastewater treatment works, located to the south east of the City of Aberdeen on the shore of Nigg Bay, serves a population of 250,000. It is operated by Scottish Water Services (Grampian), who have a 28-year design, build, finance and operation contract with Scottish Water to operate and maintain four wastewater treatment plants serving the north east of Scotland. In addition to treating wastewater, the company operates sludge treatment facilities which treats indigenous sludge and is able to receive additional imported sludge and liquid wastes.
Like many similar sites, it had been operating traditional lobe air blowers for the critical aeration processes in its Biological Air Flooded Filter (BAFF). In the process, a constant flow of low-pressure air is supplied by the blowers to BAFF media at the base of treatment tanks. This provides the oxygen required to sustain the organic bacteria that is treating the waste water with each cell air scoured and back- washed once per day.
Blowers of the type in operation at the Nigg plant have been a constant area of concern and attention for the site maintenance team. As Graham Ellis, Asset Manager of Scottish Water Services explains: “Our nineteen roots-type lobe blowers required intense levels of maintenance and were frequently unable to operate at the upper end of their performance range. There was also a high incidence of air and oil leakage to deal with. Overall, the process was running too close to the wire.”
There was also an energy cost consideration to take into account. With the majority of the blowers running 24/7, the BAFF process represents a significant share of the Nigg plant’s total energy consumption.
To remedy the situation, Graham Ellis and the management team undertook an asset liability review to determine the equipment replacement options currently available to them: “We started off with seven blower providers, went through an elimination process, based on available technology. We then did an energy study to see who had the most energy-efficient and cost-effective solution to meet our needs at which point we decided to switch from roots blowers to screw blowers. This was followed up by a maintainability and totex model which came out strongly in favour of Atlas Copco’s offering.”
The phased installation and commissioning programme, carried out by Design Air, an Atlas Copco distributor, took place over a period of six months. When taken off line, a wastewater treatment cell needs from 12-18 hours to restore its operation. As a result, each of twenty cells had to be taken offline individually, in sequence, and utilised the backup blower in order to minimise the risk to the technically sensitive process. Scottish Water was pleased that the planned process interruption was limited to just a half day per cell. As of now, the site is reporting around 25 per cent energy savings in aeration, with potential for further savings through DO (dissolved oxygen) control process optimisation. This is made possible by the ZS VSD screw blower’s turndown capabilities and superior internal air compression.
It has also enabled the Nigg plant to fully integrate all seventeen blowers into its SCADA system via Modbus protocols, utilising only two network cable runs and two Atlas Copco Mk5 Gateway units.
Such integration along with built-in independent individual control systems provides for full control and monitoring via SCADA, as well as for an emergency protocol for when those signals are lost. This ensures that every single blower can operate completely independently and could always revert to a pre-programmed operating point in case of primary signal loss.
Commenting on the success of the upgrade project, Graham Ellis had this to say:
“Before this work, regular blower failures meant we were experiencing unacceptable process and compliance risks. Now, we are able to operate reliably at the plant’s design capacity while also using less energy. What’s more, we have gone from having to spend an average of 14 hours a week maintaining the blowers to just carrying out daily checks within our service contract. Working with Atlas Copco and the installers on this project has gone exceptionally well and we have put the blowers under an Atlas Copco total responsibility service plan to ensure maximum uptime.”
There is a changing perception within the water industry that the widely used, conventional lobe blower design principle no longer meets the needs of today’s low carbon economy and that operators can benefit substantially from energy savings through the replacement of conventional lobe equipment with innovative and sustainable rotary screw technology. There is also evidence of screw blowers replacing blade-type units following comparison trial installations.