Operational factors of different water cooled compressors

Water cooled compressors require little demand from your facility's ventilation system. This is because cooling water removes approximately 90% of the heat energy created by the electric motor.

An open system without circulating water requires an external source. This includes municipal water mains, lakes, streams, or well water. After passing through the compressor, this water is discharged.

When using this method, the system needs a thermostat control to maintain desired air temperature and govern water consumption. Generally, an open system is easy and inexpensive to install. However, it's costly to run, especially if the cooling water comes from water mains.

Water from a lake or stream is typically free, but needs filtration and purification to limit the risk of clogging the cooling system. Furthermore, water rich in lime may result in boiler scale forming inside the coolers - causing impaired cooling. The same concerns apply to salt water, which may be used if the system is designed properly and dimensioned accordingly.

In an open system with circulating water, cooling water from the compressor is re-cooled in an open cooling tower. This process involves air blown through a chamber. As a result, part of the water evaporates. The remaining water is cooled to 2˚C below the ambient temperature (depending on external factors including humidity).

Open systems with circulating water are primarily used when the availability of an external water supply is limited. The disadvantage of this system is that the water gradually becomes contaminated by surrounding air. In addition, the system must be continuously filled up using external water due to evaporation.

Another downside is that dissolvable salts are deposited on the compressor's hot metal surfaces, reducing the cooling tower's heat transfer capacity. Also, the water needs regular analysis and chemical treatment to avoid algae growth.

During winter, when the compressor is not operating, it's important to drain or heat the water to prevent freezing.

In a closed cooling system, water continuously circulates between the compressor and an external heat exchanger. This heat exchanger is, in turn, cooled by either an external water circuit or surrounding air.

When a water circuit cools water, a flat plate heat exchanger is used. With surrounding air, a cooling matrix consisting of pipes and cooling fins is used. The surrounding air is forced to circulate through the pipes and fins by means of one or more fans. This method is suitable if the availability of cooling water is limited.

The cooling capacity of open or closed circuits is about the same. That is, the compressor water becomes cooled to 5 °C above the coolant temperature. If surrounding air cools the water, you'll need antifreeze (e.g. glycol).

The closed cooling water system is filled with pure, softened water. With glycol, the compressor system's water flow must be recalculated. The type and concentration of glycol affects the water's thermal capacity and viscosity.

It is also important to thoroughly clean the system before it's filled for the first time. A correctly implemented closed water system requires minimal supervision and low maintenance costs.

For installations where the available cooling water is potentially corrosive, the cooler should be designed in a corrosion-resistant material such as Incoloy.

As referenced in the introduction, most modern compressor packages are also available in an air-cooled version. This setup involves forced ventilation inside the air compressor.

As a result, higher energy is consumed due to constantly running a fan. However, air-cooled compressors tend to be cleaner with fewer contaminants running through your equipment.

We hope this article helps you understand which type of air compressor cooling method is most appropriate for your setup, application, and needs. If you require additional insight, our team is happy to help. Please feel free to get in touch today to receive custom tailored advice.